Ask Finn← Discover
Trending

A Video Game Chat Led the FBI to a Teen Held Captive for 521 Days

By Casey Morgan · Friday, November 20, 2026
Finn's Take· TL;DR
  • Kylie Arellano, missing 521 days, was located through a Discord conversation she had with a Colorado teenager in Among Us gaming app.
  • A Colorado mother investigated the girl's location using reverse property searches on Zillow photos, then contacted FBI who rescued Arellano from Oregon home.
  • Suspect Adam Harmel, 39, allegedly groomed Arellano on social media, abducted her, isolated her with weapons, and sexually assaulted her for eighteen months.
See this from any side — with sources:
Left takeNeutralRight take

An Unlikely Rescue Begins in an Online Game

Kylie Arellano was just 15 years old when she disappeared from Garden City, Utah, in May 2025. For nearly a year and a half, her family had no idea where she was. Then, in the most unexpected of places — an online multiplayer game called *Among Us* — a Colorado teenager stumbled upon her cry for help, setting off a chain of events that would ultimately bring her home.

Khristina Tresp called the way the case came together "miraculous." She said it started when her son played an online game and met a girl who needed help. The conversation began during the teenage boy's session of *Among Us* and moved to Discord. The missing girl shared with him that she was a runaway and being held against her will by a man older than her, and that he was hurting her.

A Mother's Investigation Pinpoints the Location

Tresp then began chatting with the girl herself. The girl only knew the county and the city she was in. Working with almost nothing, Tresp refused to give up. Tresp, who is based in Colorado, then did her own investigation. "She found the name of someone inside of the house so I typed that in to reverse property search, and pulled up a few addresses in the area," Tresp said.

Tresp started sending photos of homes pulled from Zillow so she could be sure the girl knew where she was. Once the girl saw the second house Tresp sent her, she confirmed, "Yes, that's it. That's where I'm at." Tresp then called the FBI, and agents arrested Harmel. Law enforcement saved Arellano from the home of Adam Hunter Harmel, 39, on November 1 — 521 days after she went missing.

The Horrors Behind Closed Doors

According to the FBI affidavit, the girl told investigators she met Harmel on social media in May 2025. Investigators allege he drove from Oregon to Perry, Utah, on or about May 29, 2025, picked her up, and drove her back to his Oregon residence. The complaint says he threw her phone into a river in Logan Canyon and told her she could not leave.

A federal criminal complaint alleges Harmel made Arellano sleep in the same bed as him and kept a knife under his pillow, forcing her to sleep against the wall to prevent her from escaping. The complaint also alleges that he sexually assaulted her and often hit her, becoming very violent and aggressive. When agents searched the house, they recovered several knives and a machete. A federal grand jury has charged Harmel with transportation with the intent to engage in criminal sexual activity. Court documents say there is evidence he tried to abduct one other minor and that he was involved in the production and distribution of child pornography.

What This Case Reveals About Online Safety

The FBI confirmed Harmel moved his conversation with Arellano off the gaming platform where they met and continued grooming her on a social media platform. A law enforcement source told *Newsweek* that Arellano and Harmel communicated on Snapchat. This case is a stark reminder that online predators frequently exploit the casual, anonymous nature of gaming platforms to make initial contact with minors before migrating to less monitored apps.

Ironically, it was that same online world that ultimately exposed him. The willingness of a teenage boy to listen, and his mother's determination to act, turned a video game chat into a lifeline. Eighteen months after Arellano vanished, the FBI found her hundreds of miles from home in Huntington, Oregon, and Harmel was taken into custody. As this case moves toward trial, it stands as both a warning about how predators operate in digital spaces and a testament to what ordinary people can accomplish when they refuse to look away.

Have a question about this story?
Ask Finn — answers grounded in this article, from any viewpoint.