Finn's Take· TL;DRAustralian cricket's most notorious chapter has been ripped back open. Eight years after the infamous Sandpapergate scandal shook the sport to its core, retired opener Usman Khawaja has dropped a bombshell: the entire Australian team knew about the sandpaper plot in Cape Town — and the cover-up that followed protected far more than just three players. Now, one of the key figures from that era is pushing back hard.
Former Australia head coach Darren Lehmann has challenged Khawaja's assertion that the entire Australian dressing room was aware of the 2018 ball-tampering plan in Cape Town. Lehmann's rebuttal, delivered publicly on Saturday, November 7, adds a fierce new layer of conflict to a saga that many in Australian cricket had hoped was finally buried.
Khawaja has claimed the entire Australia team was involved in the sandpaper plot in 2018, including using it on the ball in the Gqeberha Test prior to Cape Town, and that he was never interviewed by Cricket Australia's investigator about the incident despite sitting next to Cameron Bancroft in the dressing room. That last detail is particularly stinging — it raises serious questions about the thoroughness of the original investigation.
In his book, Khawaja claims that lighthearted discussions about the use of sandpaper at St George's Park in Gqeberha during the second Test led to Steve Smith walking out of the rooms and saying he didn't want to know about it. He claims Bancroft then volunteered to use sandpaper during South Africa's first innings at that Test. Cricket Australia's 2018 investigation found only captain Steve Smith, vice-captain David Warner, and batter Cameron Bancroft had prior knowledge of the sandpaper plot. Smith and Warner received 12-month bans and Bancroft a nine-month suspension. Khawaja's account directly contradicts those official findings.
Khawaja is set to detail his explosive claims in his autobiography *Sabr*, and he wrote the book himself without any help from an established writer or journalist. Khawaja dedicated the Sandpapergate chapter in his book to Smith, Warner, and Bancroft, writing that the trio "deserve" the "justice" of collective blame from the team.
Lehmann has strongly rejected Khawaja's claims that everyone in the Australia national cricket team knew about the sandpaper plan. Yet his defence is complicated by a remarkable admission made in the same breath. He told ABC Sport: "You do know ball tampering is going on because it's been happening for 150 years." That framing — essentially arguing that widespread cheating was simply the norm — is unlikely to satisfy critics demanding accountability.
Khawaja has also claimed that he proposed taking collective responsibility after Bancroft was exposed. However, Lehmann said he could not verify whether such a conversation had taken place, explaining that the squad was divided between separate dressing rooms and that he was occupied with meetings involving Cricket Australia. The former coach also distanced himself from another allegation concerning the origins of the sandpaper plan, saying he had no knowledge of an alleged conversation between Bancroft and a member of Australia's coaching staff that Khawaja described as significant.
Darren Lehmann, who was cleared of wrongdoing, resigned as head coach in the wake of the incident. He denied Khawaja's claims and said it "drags up some bad memories." Ahead of the book's release, current captain Pat Cummins reiterated that the issue was "dealt with then" and that the squad had moved on. But Khawaja's account makes it increasingly difficult to simply draw a line and walk away.
Khawaja directly contradicted official integrity findings ahead of his forthcoming autobiography release, saying: "The issue is that I genuinely thought after eight years the truth would have been out by now." That sentiment — the frustration of a player who watched three teammates take the fall alone — is what gives this story its real weight. Whether Cricket Australia chooses to revisit its findings or quietly let the controversy fade, Khawaja's book ensures the full reckoning with Sandpapergate is far from over.