Finn's Take· TL;DRWhen Roberta Devers, a midwife in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, did a prenatal check on an expectant mother, the woman — a member of the Amish community in her third trimester — had been sick with measles. It was not an isolated moment. It was the new normal. And it was changing everything Devers thought she knew about vaccines.
Devers, 63, has delivered nearly 2,000 babies and has cared for dozens of pregnant women infected with the virus since measles began spreading rapidly in the rural Pennsylvania county in April. She holds a degree in maternal and fetal health, but she works as an unlicensed, traditional midwife in Pennsylvania, independent of hospital systems and without physician oversight. That independence has made her a trusted figure in communities that often keep their distance from conventional medicine — and it has placed her at the center of a public health emergency she never anticipated.
Devers said she questioned immunizations as a young mother and never vaccinated her son. For years, she sat with uncertainty. "It was difficult to know who to trust and who to believe," she said. But what she has witnessed in Lancaster County has stripped away that ambiguity.
Devers said one of her young mothers went into labor at 17 weeks and lost her baby. "I had no doubt it was measles," she said. "Two weeks earlier, she had contracted measles and then had a miscarriage." Experiences like that reframed everything. "Numbers and books became people," she said. "It was humanized by watching what was happening."
Lancaster County, home to the largest Amish population in the U.S., is now the epicenter of the nation's worst measles outbreak in 35 years. Pennsylvania has the most U.S. cases, with over 1,350 this year, more than a third in Lancaster County alone. That is likely a significant undercount, community leaders say, since many people with measles never see a doctor. Five deaths have been officially linked to the outbreak among unvaccinated individuals.
Devers can give advice to isolate, minimizing the spread of the highly contagious virus. But she cannot do the thing experts say is critical in curbing the outbreak: administer measles vaccines. The Pennsylvania Health Department stated it "does not have the authority under current state law to allow traditional midwives to administer vaccines." Any change would have to come from the Legislature. State law allows certified, licensed nurse midwives to provide measles vaccines — but Devers does not hold that designation.
Families call Devers every single day. "They're pregnant and they've gotten it, or their babies have gotten it," she told reporters. "People ask me, 'Do you have that vaccine in the car?'" She doesn't. And that gap between what her community needs and what the law allows her to provide has become agonizing.
Pennsylvania's overall kindergarten MMR vaccination rate fell to 93.2% last year, which is below the 95% threshold that makes an outbreak extremely unlikely in a community. In the early 2000s, the vaccination rate in Lancaster County was around 99%, but it has decreased since the COVID-19 pandemic. That erosion of herd immunity is now playing out in the most painful possible terms.
Pennsylvania officials have invited Devers and other midwives to attend a measles education webinar — a small but notable gesture of engagement. Devers believes the state can do far more. "There's a lot of home birth midwives in the state of Pennsylvania, and if they were given the opportunity to immunize, it would be another opportunity to quickly get people vaccinated," she told reporters. In tight-knit rural communities where trust is everything and doctors are strangers, a familiar face carrying a vaccine could make all the difference. The question now is whether Pennsylvania's lawmakers will act before more families have to grieve.